Former Cabela’s CEO’s Lake Vermilion Home Lists for $3.5 Million

Former Cabela’s CEO’s Lake Vermilion Home Lists for $3.5 Million

The former Cabela’s CEO’s Lake Vermilion summer retreat is officially on the market, and it is one of the more interesting northern Minnesota lake home listings of the year. Dennis Highby’s family is selling the nine-acre Frazer Bay property for $3.5 million, fully furnished.

The Story Behind Blue Eagle

Highby joined Cabela’s as its 40th employee and eventually became CEO, helping turn the company into one of the largest outdoor retailers in the country. His plan was to retire by 60 and spend more time on the water. He handed the search to his wife, Linda, and her mother, who spent three days touring listings up north while he fished.

Lake Vermilion was a natural fit. Linda’s grandfather started making annual trips there in the 1940s, and Dennis first saw the lake on their honeymoon in 1970. The family bought the compound on the eve of the Great Recession, after the seller had already cut the price twice. With four kids and 13 grandchildren, it became the family’s summer base, complete with lakeside bonfires, sauna plunges, berry picking on a spot they named Blueberry Hill, and a Fourth of July tradition.

Dennis passed away in early 2026. Linda says the trip from Sidney, Nebraska, nearly 1,000 miles, is simply too far now.

What $3.5 Million Buys on Lake Vermilion

The 4,600 square foot main house was built in 2001 and has five bedrooms, five bathrooms, and custom kitchens on both levels. Every main living space faces the lake, including the primary suite and a great room with timber trusses and a large stone fireplace. The lower level walks out to the beach and adds:

  • A rec room
  • A second fireplace
  • Three bedrooms
  • Two bathrooms

In-floor heat and central air round it out.

Outside, there are two guest cabins, a lakeside sauna, and 130 feet of sugar sand beach. The listing agent, Lisa Janisch, points to the west-facing exposure and a four-mile, island-studded view down Frazer Bay as the features that are hardest to find.

How This Listing Compares to the Lake Vermilion Market

Here is the number that jumps out. Janisch says she closed a $1.8 million sale on the lake this November, the most expensive in two years. This listing is asking nearly double that.

The broader market is wide open. Nearly 90 homes and cabins on and near Lake Vermilion are listed right now, from a $114,900 house in Tower to a $4.95 million, 48-acre compound. A rustic water-access cabin is listed at $259,000. Janisch says turnkey properties are still getting strong interest as the lake market heads into its slowest season, and there is now a healthy inventory above $1 million.

For Twin Cities buyers weighing a lake place up north, that combination matters. More inventory at the top end and a slower season usually means more room to negotiate, and a listing like this one will test how high prices on Lake Vermilion can go. If you are comparing a cabin purchase with a move closer to home, [INTERNAL LINK: Twin Cities east metro luxury homes or lake home buying guide] is a good place to start.

Hot Tips around the Twin Cities? Need Help Buying or Selling 🏡?
🙋🏻‍♂️DM me or Text📲 Darin Bjerknes 612-702-5126

Work With Darin

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.

Follow Me on Instagram